Why Cities Are Running Out of Affordable Housing — And What’s Being Done
Across the United States and many parts of the world, a growing crisis is taking shape: the shortage of affordable housing. From teachers and nurses to service workers and young professionals, millions of people are being priced out of the communities where they live and work. Meanwhile, cities are struggling to respond with policies that are both effective and politically viable.
But how did we get here? And more importantly, what’s being done—on both the public and private sides—to reverse the trend?
This blog explores the key reasons cities are running out of affordable housing and the most promising solutions being implemented to close the gap.
What Exactly Is “Affordable Housing”?
Before diving into the causes and solutions, it’s worth defining the term.
Affordable housing generally refers to housing that costs no more than 30% of a household’s income. This applies whether someone is renting or owning. For lower-income earners, that typically translates to below-market-rate homes or units subsidized in some form.
It’s not just a low-income issue. Increasingly, middle-income earners are also finding themselves locked out of housing in major metropolitan areas, a phenomenon known as the "missing middle" crisis.
The Main Causes of the Affordable Housing Shortage
1. Supply vs. Demand Imbalance
Urban populations are growing faster than the rate of new housing construction. In many cases, housing supply simply can’t keep up with demand. Zoning restrictions, permitting delays, and neighborhood opposition (NIMBYism) have slowed construction.
In high-demand cities like San Francisco, New York, and Austin, years-long project timelines make it nearly impossible for supply to keep pace with the influx of new residents.
2. Rising Construction Costs
Labor shortages, rising material costs, and lengthy regulatory processes have all driven up the cost of building. Developers, facing higher expenses, often choose to build luxury units to maximize returns—leaving fewer affordable options on the table.
3. Gentrification and Displacement
As formerly neglected neighborhoods become more desirable, property values and rents rise. Longtime residents can be priced out, with no comparable options nearby. This process contributes to the gradual erosion of affordable housing stock.
4. Loss of Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing (NOAH)
Many affordable units are not subsidized but are naturally cheaper due to age or condition. Unfortunately, these properties are increasingly being purchased by investors, upgraded, and re-rented at higher prices—a process known as value-add repositioning.
5. Insufficient Public Investment
Decades of underinvestment in public housing and subsidies have left a large portion of low-income families without support. Federal spending on housing assistance has stagnated, even as need has increased.
What’s Being Done — Promising Strategies and Policies
While the challenge is massive, cities, developers, nonprofits, and lawmakers are testing a variety of strategies to reverse the trend. Some are new, some are decades old—but all are part of a growing push to restore balance in the housing market.
1. Zoning Reform
Single-family zoning—which prohibits the construction of duplexes, triplexes, or apartments in many neighborhoods—has been identified as a major obstacle to affordability.
Cities like:
Minneapolis have abolished single-family zoning citywide.
Portland allows up to fourplexes on most residential lots.
California passed SB 9, allowing lot splits and duplex construction on single-family parcels.
Zoning reform increases the density of housing supply and encourages more small-scale development in urban cores.
2. Inclusionary Housing Policies
Many cities require or incentivize developers to include a percentage of affordable units in new developments.
For example:
New York City offers density bonuses in exchange for setting aside units for low-income tenants.
Denver and Boston have adopted mandatory inclusionary zoning for large projects.
While not a silver bullet, these policies can integrate affordable housing into market-rate developments.
3. Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs)
Governments are increasingly working with private developers to create or preserve affordable housing. This often involves:
Low-interest loans
Tax credits (like the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit, or LIHTC)
Land contributions or long-term leases
In return, developers agree to set rents below market rate for a fixed period.
4. Community Land Trusts (CLTs)
CLTs are nonprofit organizations that acquire land and keep it permanently affordable by separating land ownership from housing ownership. Homebuyers lease the land at low cost and agree to resale restrictions that maintain affordability for future buyers.
Cities like Atlanta, San Francisco, and Chicago are expanding CLTs to combat displacement.
5. Adaptive Reuse of Commercial Spaces
With a surplus of office and retail space post-COVID, some cities are converting vacant buildings into housing. These conversions can be faster and more cost-effective than new construction—especially when supported by tax incentives or grants.
Recent projects in Los Angeles, Philadelphia, and Detroit have shown promising results.
6. Preservation of Existing Affordable Housing
Instead of focusing solely on new construction, some cities are prioritizing the preservation of existing affordable units. Tools include:
Subsidizing repairs for landlords who keep rents low
Offering grants or tax breaks to maintain older buildings
Creating housing trust funds to acquire at-risk properties
Preservation is often faster and cheaper than building new units from scratch.
The Private Sector’s Role
While government action is critical, private investors and landlords also have a role to play. Strategies include:
Building with modular construction to reduce costs
Partnering with housing nonprofits for mixed-income developments
Utilizing social impact funds to finance affordable housing with lower expected returns
Additionally, tech platforms like PadSplit (for co-living) or Divvy Homes (rent-to-own models) are introducing alternative paths to affordability.
The Road Ahead: Challenges and Hope
The affordable housing crisis is complex and rooted in decades of policy, economic shifts, and demographic changes. There’s no one-size-fits-all solution—but a multi-pronged approach is gaining traction in cities that recognize the urgency.
Ultimately, the path forward will require:
Political will
Cross-sector collaboration
Innovative financing
Public support for denser, more inclusive communities
The cost of inaction is clear: economic stagnation, homelessness, and deepening inequality. But with the right tools and mindset, cities can turn the tide.
Relocating or downsizing? Instant Home Cash Offer and move on your timeline.